Qvisory™ - Tools for Life

Welcome! Please log in or register.

RSS

SmartyPig Says It's Smart to Save

Jason Simon

Jason Simon

Posted Apr. 02, 2008
Tagged: ,

Are you in a situation where you respond to the idea of saving money with, "When pigs fly!"? Well, SmartyPig, a new and different way to save money, believes that saving will never be the same. Is this so?

SmartyPig started when several entrepreneurs decided to create a savings tool that enables you to set specific savings goals, accept contributions to your goal from a variety of sources (yourself and others), and make distributions on a recurring basis. According to their website:

SmartyPig is a simple, smart, fun way to save for a specific goal. Using groundbreaking technology and the latest in security standards, SmartyPig allows you to invite family and friends to contribute to your account, gives you additional incentive boosts from top retailers who sell exactly what you’re saving for AND 4.30% (APY) interest on the money you’re saving. Simple, Smart, Savings. SmartyPig!

How does SmartyPig differ from traditional savings accounts?

Users are encouraged to create savings goals, which can be made public or private. Public goals can be funded with the support of outside contributors such as friends, parents, or grandparents. Contributions are made by credit card with a maximum charge of $500, and a per transaction processing fee of $4.95.

Is SmartyPig a smart choice for you?

Saving for specific goals is a great idea for all of us, but is SmartyPig the best way to do it? It seems to me there are a few things that prospective users should watch out for.

  • If you don't pay off the credit card that you made the SmartyPig contribution with, you'll be paying more later.
  • Is your credit card interest rate and the $4.95 transaction processing fee for every contribution made worth the savings interest earned?
  • Money contributed cannot be withdrawn until the savings goal is met or canceled by the primary account holder (though goals can be changed at anytime until the point of redemption).

When you meet or close a SmartyPig saving goal, you receive your savings plus interest through a Smarty Pig MasterCard Debit Card or on the gift card of a retailer partnering with the company. You cannot transfer SmartyPig funds to a third party financial institution like your bank, but you may take your funds via check. And watch out – if you request a check, a $25 processing fee is tagged on.

And who are these Best-In-Class Retailers? Amazon, Best Buy, The Home Depot, and L.L. Bean are just a few. If you're looking to buy a specific product at one of these or other retailers on the site, SmartyPig may interest you. Participating retailers add up to a 5% bonus to the savings goal, but if you are looking to save for the long term, and not to purchase more products, this probably isn't for you.

Read what others have to say:


SmartyPig is trying to do something different, but it seems to make saving money cost money. Online savings tools are a relatively new concept. Would you use a tool like SmartyPig? How do you save for a specific purchase?

My name is Jason Simon and I am your Qvisory Money Content Manager.

Money matters to me as much as it probably matters to you. I know what it’s like to feel anxious, confused, and angry while trying to figure out how much to spend on rent, where to find a job, or which credit card to use. These are the types of decisions we all must face.

I strongly believe that Qvisory is opening a space to discuss these issues, learn from each other, and creatively advocate for money, work, and health issues that affect our daily life.

In addition to writing about money issues at Qvisory, I blog at Open to Difference. I graduated from George Mason University with a M.S. in Conflict Analysis & Resolution and the University of California, Santa Cruz with a B.A. in Sociology and Community Studies. See Jason Simon's other posts and profile.

Qvisory's educational content is supported in part by the Qvisory Education Fund.

Got an opinion? Speak out on news and issues. Submit a blog post or video to Qvisory.

2 Comments

Jason Simon
04/11/08 03:45 PM

It does sound complicated. Setting up a basic savings account seems easier. You can review the highest interest yield accounts available at www.bankrate.com

DummyPig
04/10/08 08:08 PM

SmartyPig sounds complicated! Maybe that's the point, they make saving so complicated that you do it accidentally? Personally, I don't see what's wrong with just putting money into a savings account!

Comment on this

To create a hyperlink, simply type the URL.

YouTube video links like http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abCxyZ will automatically be converted to embed the actual video in your comment.

(Your name will be displayed next to your comment.)

(Your email will not be shown, or shared.)


Yes, I'd like to receive emails from Qvisory with information about the organization’s activities and advocacy campaigns.

(optional)


Log in or Register (Not required to submit your comment.)

Spread the word

Get Involved

Get updates with tips, tools, and action alerts on money, work, and health.

Email

Take action. Make change in the corridors of power.

Take control. Manage your life and reach your goals.

Got an opinion? Speak out on news and issues. Submit a blog post or video to Qvisory.

 

Also on Tools for Life

All Posts

Other Posts

Related Posts - Recent Posts